Comments
Generalisations are lazy and can be dangerous
Generalisations are just that, general.
Generalisations should be handled with care
Updates on SOS survey and the Democrats
Robert Hoddle wrote the following, containing updates regarding the SOS survey:
Good on you for the CDB article
"Victorian Candidates who support wider public debate on stable population - per SOS survey"
Sat, 2014-11-22 23:15 which has kindly just been forwarded to me.
1) Are you aware that our most important candidate - Steven Armstrong - is missing from the article?
His results only went onto the SOS website yesterday as at
Latest update of individual responses: 141122 Planning Survey Candidates RO
http://sos.asn.au/vic/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/141122-Planning-Survey-Candidates-RO1.xlsx
It would be useful for completeness if the article included his results.
2) I found the Australian Democrats are unusual in having an explicit sustainable population policy as on their website at Population and Immigration. (pdf)
URL http://sos.asn.au/vic/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/141122-Planning-Survey-Candidates-RO1.xlsx viz..
"To ensure our continent’s long-term sustainability, we aim to first stabilise then reduce Australia’s population to an ecologically sustainable level."
Sadly in contradiction of this, I found in recent personal conversation with their Vic Upper House candidate (Southern Metropolitan Region), Clive Jackson from Oakleigh that he personally is quite unconcerned about rapid population growth and high immigration as "there is plenty of room left". [Guaranteed exact quote from personal convo last week]. His bio, otherwise environmentally aware, is at http://vic.australian-democrats.org.au/ He is actually a planner with the Victorian Dept of Human Services (DHS) concerned about housing unaffordability. Yet he has apparently not made the direct connection between high immigration and housing unaffordability.
Robert Hoddle
Boomers were largely catered to
Point well made...but
I don't understand the Greens
Immigration and Human Rights
Voice of the West and other Niddrie candidates
SOS question on population
Voices of the West irony!
Vote for Phil Cleary - Northern Metropolitan Region
If in the Northern Metropolitan Region consider voting for Phil Cleary, opponent of the East West Link and advocate of public transport. When a Federal MP for Wills he saved the Upfield rail line from closure. Where would the northern suburbs be now if this vital line had been closed? For many years Phil has been a great supporter of Protectors of Public Lands Victoria and parks groups in Melbourne.
See Age article 22 November 2014 "Cleary wants apology for provocation defence" This is part of his long standing campaign regarding domestic violence.
http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/victoria-state-election-2014/cleary-wants-apology-for-provocation-defence-20141121-11r56a.html
"Your" ABC anoints corporate 'right to rule' Australia
Victoria's stretched economy is failing!
Simpson's creator Sam Simon supports Sea Shepherd
Trees and vegetation lower temperatures
Homeless being mainly ignored in Victorian election
Population Policies
All of Melbourne suffering from similar issues
One only has to read the election issues facing different suburbs, and they are almost ALL the same all over Melbourne: unemployment, traffic congestion, over developments, shortage of schools, health care, a growth of crime and drugs. Each electorate seems to be coping with similar issues, but on different magnitudes. The one thing that's common to all is population growth - but the public seem to be willing to swallow the inevitability of it all!
While property developers, planners and banks make huge profits, the public are meant to bear the stress and the squeeze of overloaded infrastructure, over-crowding and rising costs of living. There's no parties committed to addressing the population issue - except for Steven Armstrong, Independent in Albert Park but supported by the Sustainable Population Party (SPP).
We Will Decide- the Democratic way to decide migration
Stop the Trawler Alliance: PETITION
Vote 1 John Carbonari - Australia First Party
Housing BOOM!
The Housing Bubble We Have To Have
Neoliberal governments at all levels of all persuasions have been, and still are, banking on the housing industry to keep their heads above water. As the Australian recession tightens its grip on these same governments, they espouse more of the same. Reliance on the mining and housing industries is like flogging a dead horse in the Melbourne Cup, it's not getting us anywhere let alone making us a dollar.
These governments are bereft of any idea how to stimulate the economy which is being strangled by high net migration, employment opportunities and a fractured taxation system. Governments are bullied by big business who are marching to a beat of a different drum to 99% of Australian citizens. The revolving door between big business and government has rendered government ie the major parties Labor and the Coalition, craven to an extent where government does the bidding of big business.
The demise of the manufacturing industry, while not the be all and end all of industries, was skills based, unlike the service industry which is supposed to replace it. Further to this the lack of investment in the education, health, agricultural, renewable energy, to name a few industries, has produced a future outlook that is very grim indeed. With youth unemployment running at up to 25%, the jobs market is extremely bleak for even our best qualified youth. Competition between these kids and allegedly skilled migrants is skyrocketing with all too often the migrants winning out because they are prepared to work for less cash and in poorer conditions.
Less cash in the market place only adds to our woes. Whether it be migrants earning less or a former tradesperson earning less as a cleaner, less lass cash means less sales. This in itself is not a problem, but it adds to the cycle of workers being laid off. This is the classic neoliberal conundrum and the very reason why neoliberalism will never work!
Those who control the strings will make a killing while those below, the majority, will struggle and some will not survive. This cold harsh reality of our governments' decision making. We get told after the event of what is going to happen a la East West Link and the Desal Plant. You've got it, it's going to cost you a packet, does it work? - who cares!!!
November 29 is polling day, I beg readers to keep the above in mind when voting. A vote for either of the major parties is for more of the same. More bad decisions, a housing market that's set to explode, less jobs, more misery and more people on the dole!!!
Thank you, Waiona, for this insightful contribution. Please consider also having having a look at
Issues that should be decided at the 29 November Victorian State elections (14/11/14, also at candobetter.net/MakeYourVoteCount) and give us your thoughts. - Ed
GDP Growth lagging behind population growth
Mallee birds extinct in 20 years: government policy to blame
Planned Burns in habitat forests
Save our Ducks: In The Age today!
Indicators
GDP growth is narrow, and needs to be redefined for 21st century
Berlin and growth
GDP indicator of prosperity, not cause
Greg Hunt: the prize for being the Anti-Environment Minister
An Environment Minister who refuses to agree with a sustainable population policy, and approve of our ridiculously high rates of immigration, is an oxymoron! What other factor are creating all the environmental challenges of today other than humans, and are not being exacerbated by swelling human numbers? Of course, there is climate change, which is anthropogenic, and feral species, which is also a problem created by humans!
An Environment Minister who fails to acknowledge human impacts on the environment, and that population growth will natural increase the threats, is a contradiction. It's like a church pastor being an atheist, the fox in charge of the hens, a criminal gang running the police force, a speaker in a Temperance Society advertising alcohol, a Christian missionary running a brothel!
We've had some very mediocre "environment" Ministers in the past, but Greg Hunt should receive a special prize as the most UN-environmental- Minister of all time!
An Auditor-General's report has highlighted serious problems with the department's enforcement of environment laws, and failures to check on new mines, waste dumps and resource developments, and slammed its "passive" approach to ensuring developers comply with conditions to protect areas such as the Great Barrier Reef. The department was too under-staffed to administer Australia's Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act and officials were not properly trained to monitor the activities of developers.
It's the Environment Department to support if you don't want one! With the Abbott government's anti-science and climate change stance, and being "open for business" globally, they don't want "science" or the "environment" to get in the way of economics, and "progress"!
We can only admire MP Kelvin Thomson for audacity of addressing some of the unwelcome questions to our government! He's the thorn in the flesh, the one who makes our politicians uncomfortable for their hypocrisy, and makes them squirm with pertinent questions that uncovers their deceptions, and contradictions.
Our gate-keepers and office-holders need to be ethical, moral and have the highest integrity. Now, they are selected to fit the party policies, rather than be qualified in their departmental folios. It's Orwellian:
“Doublethink means the power of holding two contradictory beliefs in one's mind simultaneously, and accepting both of them.”– George Orwell, 1984
Public Transport demo - 1pm, 15 Nov, Melbourne
Following our Rally4PT (28 June) which was endorsed by over
60 Victorian community groups and leading up to the State Election in
November, we are determined to continue to keep our 3 demands in the
campaign to stop East West Link front and centre in the minds of pollies
and voters, and to demand an integrated public transport system for
Victoria.
Can you and your organisation
help publicise and support our second Rally4PT - The Transport Election: We demand our say! to be held:
Saturday, 15 November,
1pm
State Library lawns,
corner LaTrobe and Swanston Streets, Melbourne
- speakers (to be announced
soon) will give updates on this campaign and discuss further action for the
remaining weeks to the 29 November.
We hope your group can
take part. It's vital that we send both major political parties a clear
message.
DIY/BYO signage and placards are also warmly encouraged. (eg
Doncaster, Rowville, Mernda, Mildura, Wyndham etc)
See attached leaflet for further information and for circulation.
Facebook event: https://www.facebook.
sharing.
Further information on Rally for Public Transport: http://www.ycat.
Follow #Rally4PT on Twitter: https://twitter.com/
cheers,
Jill Koppel
On behalf of the Community campaign to stop East West Link and
invest in real public transport
and
supported by
Collingwood and Abbotsford Residents Association
Website: http://cararesidents.
Australia's economic 'growth' hides increasing poverty
We are told that one of the most notable aspects of recent Australian history has been unbroken economic prosperity. We are told about more than two decades of growth, the proceeds of the mining boom, the benefits of deregulation, and 'dodging the bullet' of the Global Financial Crisis through clever economic policy measures. The GFC is being used as a scapegoat for poor economic management, and tunnel-vision on monetary values rather than per capita GDP growth, and social welfare.
ACOSS' 2014 report on poverty in Australia, finding that 13.9% of people in Australia are living in poverty, and 17.7% of all children. "The Government appears to have developed a country growth plan for the G20 without engagement with those who will be most affected - the community," said ACOSS CEO Dr Cassandra Goldie.
The report provides the most up to date picture of poverty in the nation drawing on new data released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics Income and Expenditure surveys for 2011-12 and previous years.
In Victoria, in July our unemployment rate hit 7%, the highest rate since 2001. This is the tenth month in a row that unemployment in Victoria has been above 6 per cent. With the closure of many manufacturing industries and a high population growth rate, it's clear that more needs to be done to create new jobs. At the same time, the housing industry is "booming", and spreading the few jobs being created even further between more people.
Our measure of economic growth, based on population growth, is being used to hide the poverty and the dysfunctional nature of our economy. Population growth is the no-brainer, lazy way of boosting the size of our economy. The more of us there are, the more thinly our natural and built resources are spread and shared out between a swelling number of people. The disproportionate urbanisation of Australia is not only placing a strain on the large cities, but is keeping regional centres from reaching their full potential. The great big Ponzi scheme of perpetual economic growth means feasting and gorging at the top of the pyramid of wealth, and discarding the less well-off on it's way!
Sir David Attenborough pleads to save Leadbeater's possum
Adapted from the Herald Sun, 10 Nov 2014:
Sir David Attenborough has weighed into the state election, backing a call for the creation of a Great Forest National Park to protect the state faunal emblem, the Leadbeater’s possum.
David Attenborough supported the creation of of a new National park in the Yarra Ranges and the Central Highlands that is 89% of Victorians.
Sir David said: “The maintenance of an intact ecological system is the only way to ensure the continued existence of biodiversity, safeguard water supplies and provide spiritual nourishment for ourselves and future generations.
World to breach IPCC's carbon limit by 2040
David Packham
"Expert " said 8%-12% of Victoria should be burned
Report from conference: Prescribed burns - state arson!
Frankston Beach Assn AGM - Nov 19- Speaker Neil Blake
Invitation to the Frankston Beach Association’s Annual General Meeting 2014.
Guest speaker 'Port Phillip Bay Keeper' Neil Blake will discuss ‘NAVIGATING COASTAL PLANNING’.
All welcome. Please invite your friends and neighbours.
Wednesday November 19th at 7.30pm
LONG ISLAND TENNIS CLUB (Corner Nepean Highway and Gould Street, Frankston)
Light refreshments served
The association reports that they have just won a grant of $8792 for ‘Sand dune
regeneration to combat storm surges’ and that this year the tea tree flowers have been stunning.
"Valuing Secularism in Syria" promoted elsewhere
The following comment, which quotes from the start of this article, was posted to the "Monday message board" of the johnquiggin.com forum discussion web site. Comments posted by myself or James to that web site often don't attract much interest from other site visitors, but in recent days our posts have drawn interest, including from one other contributor who expressed some support.
Thank you James. On the subject of Syria, I have just published an excellent speech by Susan Dirgham, National Coordinator of "Australians for Mussalah (Reconciliation) in Syria" at http://candobetter.net/node/4170, for anyone who would like to understand more. Susan is worried that if Syrian government falls, the danger of WW3 will be acute, and I agree. She compares the situation now to the one accompanying the Vietnam war, in terms of what is needed to stand up to propaganda.
She writes, "And at that time, in the US especially, it required informed, courageous individuals in the media, in churches and academia to challenge those lies in order for there to be peace. And in the countries of Indo-China, an extraordinary level of courage and resilience was needed to survive war. To sow sectarian hatred, to damn a person or a group of people or even another nation only takes a few stories, repeated over a period of time by people in positions of influence and then accepted as a truth." Susan identifies a formula for writing [propaganda] on the conflict in Syria. It is to invoke the use of chemical weapons by the Assad government as if this were established fact and to "Damn Assad and the Alawites and your article has a good chance of getting published even if you know virtually nothing." She gives the example of a Waleed Aly article doing just this, ironically just a week after the presidential election in Syria when there was a truly exceptional voter turnout and the president received overwhelming endorsement by Syrians. At the end of her speech, Susan warns that if Syria falls the danger of World War Three will be acute. Susan’s highly informative and moving speech was delivered at a Social Policy Connections Public Forum at The Study Centre, Yarra Theological Union, on 6 November. The speech was filmed and we hope to be able to link to the film soon.
Past harsh rule seen as necessary for survival of Syrian state?
This is to be posted to johnquiggin.com .
Thank for that insight into the Syrian conflict. You wrote on November 7th, 2014 at 18:02 :
"[The Syrian Christian] explained to me that Assad's foot on the throat of all warring ethnicities was the best rule the place could have. ... Sometimes a dictatorship is better than the alternative. The colonial boundaries imposed geopolitical proximity to warring ethnicities, religions and factions thereof."
I suggest that that more accurately describes the rule of President Hafez al-Assad (1930-2000) than that of his son, Bashar.
To me, it seems plausible that, in the circumstances faced by Hafez al-Assad, he may have felt that he had no choice but to resort to very harsh measures in order to stay in power, prevent invasion and prevent ethnic strife. The video broadcaster known as The Syrian Girl, who, in 2014, is an outspoken supporter of Syria, actually fled from Syria with her family to escape persecution. So, presumably, even many loyal Syrians suffered unfairly at the hands of President Hafez al-Assad.
Bashar al-Assad (born 1965), who trained in London as an ophthalmologist, has a somewhat different style to his father. Whilst he has show himself to be just as capable as his father of making the harsh decisions necessary for the survival of the Syrian state, he has also shown himself capable of governing Syria in a way that is remarkably free and open in the face of a bloody terrorist war.
On 4 June 2014 at an election which was certified as free and fair by a large number of international observers, he was elected by a huge majority of Syrian voters. according to Wikipedia, 88.7% of the 73.42% of eligible Syrian voters who were able to vote amid the war and chaos, voted for President Bashar al-Assad.
What leader of any of the Western countries hostile to Syria can claim anywhere near as much support?
Sadly this story has largely been hidden from most Australians by the lying newsmedia.
Many believe in the Cornucopian myth!
and it gets worse for Australian cattle
Bushfire risk measured as Disastrous for Victoria
Sign the petition to stop BHP locking locals out of jobs!
Stance by Russia, Syria against NATO supported by the evidence
This was posted to johnquiggin.com on 4 September at 13:19.
J-D wrote on November 3rd, 2014 at 07:42:
I could go on to quote from other sources, ...
Or, perhaps, you could just respond to the arguments I posted above (on November 3rd, 2014 at 02:03). If you were to dispute any of what I have written, you could always ask me to provide sources.
As it is, in the copy of the post on my own web site linked to above, as well as two links to the FIDH, there is a link to one other article on my own web site which has been republished from rt _dot_ com . That article includes that 2:05 video of Natalya Poklonskaya. If you look at the tags at the foot of the article I have linked to here, you will find a large number of articles, most of which also contain citations from elsewhere.
Tags at the bottom of that article include: anime, Crimea, feminism, Japan, Natalya Poklonskaya, NATO sanctions and Ukraine.
The following posted to johnquiggin.com on 4 Nov 2014 at 23:26.
J-D wrote on November 3rd, 2014 at 07:42; November 4th, 2014 at 17:12 and November 4th, 2014 at 19:15
... what kind of sources you regard as reliable, and why[?]
I would have thought the answer was self evident:
The sources, I find reliable are those which I have cited in the various discussions on this site and on my own web site.
Why do I find them reliable?
I find the reliable, because no-one – least of all, you – have been able to show me that any article, cited by me, is wrong.
Of course, feel free to prove me wrong. Just choose any article written on my own site, candobetter -dot- net or any of the other sites I listed in the Gough Whitlam discussion:
globalresearch -dot- ca, voltairenet -dot- org, landdestroyer -dot- blogspot -dot- com, presstv -dot- com and rt -dot- com
... and show all of us, with evidence and logic, how wrong it is.
Of course, I won't hold my breath waiting.
Neoliberal Dogma
After reading Bill Gammage's "Biggest Estate on Earth" and watching indigenous Australians on NITV talk about their culture, I'm often left in tears. The invasion of Australia by gubbas has been catastrophic not only for the first nations, but for the Australian biota as a whole. Our current attitude is governed by neoliberal dogma that predicates that this attitude shall continue to dominate our thinking well into the future.
Both major political parties, governments at all levels, the mass media, big business, think tanks and many more are craven to neoliberalism. Neoliberalism which became entrenched in Australia from the advent of the Hawke Labor government in 1983 and has dominated political thinking ever since. This is the same doctrine that lead the world to the economic recession/depression of 2007. The global economy was changed forever! Nothing will be the same again despite what the economic rationalists will tell you. Inequality is here to stay as is the high growth economy especially high population growth which is being promoted by the above governments, etc. Furthermore, the current Abbott Coalition federal government with its neoconservative agenda will drive austerity measures to the hilt.
In Victoria, both the Coalition and the Labor party have jumped into bed with James Packer and his cronies at Crown in the sweetest of sweetheart deals. A vote for either party in the forthcoming state election will be a vote for more of the same in years to come. How many times, in recent years, has a government been elected on a given mandate only for that government to veer off on a tangent with secretive backroom deals? Too many! Australians, indeed Victorians, must be courageous enough to prevent this from happening. Despite the gnashing of teeth, the squealing and other fallacious arguments from the mainstream media, minority governments can make better and more decisions than majority governments. We need to send the major parties a message that enough is enough by voting elsewhere whether it be the Greens, another party or an independent. As Gough would say: "It's time"!!
Climate science funding continues to be cut - and must be!
"Technological development has been allowed to advance without the associated social intelligence". Governments are now gagged and hand-cuffed by their own contractions, and ineptitude, due to vested interests.
How can Australia have a part in tackling the global threat of climate change when our coal industry and exports are almost second to non in the world? It's too lucrative to leave it in the ground.
We can't be world leaders, or co-operate in climate change efforts, while our country is making mega profits from coal exports.
The Abbott government can only cut funding to climate change research, and go into full-scale denial!
Australia won't be ready to respond and predict impacts of climate change, and whole areas of research are losing funding. These concerns come as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a United Nations body, released its latest report warning of irreversible damage from global warming, and climate scientists from the CSIRO, the Bureau of Meteorology and universities rush to meet Wednesday's deadline to apply for funds under the reduced National Environmental Science Programme (NESP).
SMH: climate science funding deadline looms
At the same time, we have an economy that's evolved to be locked into to high population growth, meaning that even if per capita levels of carbon emissions are reduced, in absolute terms they will continue to rise due to sheer numbers of people - consumers of fossil fuels.
Over the weekend, the government announced the Climate Change Ambassador's title would become just Ambassador for the Environment when the current holder Justin Lee steps down. Even the "environment" doesn't get much profile. We have a world heritage natural jewel of the Great Barrier Reef, but even it's protection won't stop coal-laden ships export coal near the reefs.
Sign Community petition to stop East West Link
Direct Action on Climate change - burn native forests!
Earning carbon credits from native forests is the forest management model of the future.
Government budget cuts continue to bite at Australia’s premier science organisation and one union says it threatens Prime Minister Tony Abbott's direct action policy.
CSIRO’s research into understanding bushfires includes detailed reconstruction, fuel modelling, research into fire suppression and recurrence and management of the Pyrotron - a bushfire wind tunnel that allows researchers to conduct controlled experiments into fire behaviour. So, without scientific backing, politicians are not confined to control, or logic.
Environment minister Greg Hunt hailed the passage as ‘real and practical action to achieve our emissions goals and targets without a carbon tax’. The Direct Action package that will allow for Tasmania native forests to be cut down and burned to generate electricity. So we now know that there is the potential for the clearing of our native forests and the use of wood products that are harvested from those forests to be considered as eligible carbon farming initiatives.
The majority of Australians want to see protection of our native forests, it is going to be opening the door for logging of those native forests—and getting further subsidies for doing that—and destroying our native forests by burning them in forest furnaces for energy.
Australia has a climate policy again – sort of (31/110/14)
March claims of Crimean human rights abuses since 'forgotten' ?
This is to be contributed to a forum discussion on johnquiggin.com
J-D wrote on November 2nd, 2014 at 07:24 :
'Other people do worse things' is neither a justification nor even a mitigation.
Where did I write that the staged murders by the neo-Nazi putschists in January and February and its subsequent war against the people of East Ukraine justifies the persecution of gays in Russia?
On November 1st, 2014 at 21:59 I wrote that, in comparison to the war crimes of the Ukraine regime and the even greater crimes of the the United States in Iraq, Libya and Syria, "the prohibition of 'propaganda on non-traditional sexual relations' seems almost insignificant by comparison."
We may have to differ on whether the latter is 'trivial' or 'insignificant' in comparison to the former, but I fail to see how the latter could any way be likened to the former.
JD wrote on November 2nd, 2014 at 07:25 :
I can see that the FIDH is no more than yet another a vehicle to manufacture pretexts for the many wars launched by the United States in recent decades. This is shown by its article "Crimea: 16 March referendum not admissible in international law" (16/3/14).
"Since the announcement of the 'referendum', the self-proclaimed Crimean authorities, supported by the deployment on the territory of increasing numbers of Russian military forces, have carried out abductions and expulsions towards continental Ukraine pro-unity activists, acts of intimidation of local communities, and the closing down of all independent media, thereby violating Ukrainian and international Human Rights legislation. Given the lack of security, many persons are presently fleeing from Crimean territory.
...
"At the same time, the Russian media under government control have organised a continuous disinformation campaign, pretexting the defence of ethnic minorities for propagating a message of hatred and threats. The representatives of the Russian and Jewish minorities in Ukraine, along with the Crimean Tatars, have frequently denounced such an attitude."
Curiously the FIDH has had nothing more to say about Crimea in the ensuing 8 months in spite of the ominous developments of which it wrote in that article.
I would have particularly thought the FIDH would have had a lot to say about the Crimean prosecutor, Natalya Poklanskaya. Surely Natalya would have to have been complicit in all of the crimes of which FIDH complains? But, not a word has been written of her by the FIDH.
A good many who read about Natalya and see her astonishing youthful good looks, whose anime-style images have gained her overwhelming popularity, particularly in Japan, would inevitably want to know why she, and the near unanimous majority of Crimeans, have supported the Russian government against the Kiev regime. If this were to happen, a vastly greater number of people would scrutinise the Ukraine narrative of both the Western mainstream media the FIDH and see it for the tissue of lies that it is.
The claims made against the Syrian government by the FIDH are no less deceitful. Much of the fearful 195,000 death toll in that conflict is the consequence of such lies by phony human rights organisations such as FIDH.
Class Action against our Government re. live export anguish
Israel's hostility to many who fought the Nazis, including JFK
The following was also posted to johnquiggin.com .
Megan @ (#25(?),) November 1st, 2014 at 21:10
Curiously, less than two decades later, JFK, whose brother Joe had died fighting the Nazis in Europe and who, himself, almost perished in 1943 when PT109 was sunk by the Japanese, was to be menaced by the pro-Israel lobby in the US. Check out Kennedy, the Lobby and the bomb of May 2013 on Voltaire Net. This shows that if the USS Liberty incident had not been witnessed by a Soviet warship, there would have been no survivors and the incident would have been blamed on Egypt, thus providing a pretext for the United States to intervene in the Six Day War on the side of Israel against Egypt. We came that close to having the Six Day War turn into a far more terrible conflagration in the Mediterranean.
Corrupt and weak...
Petition Signed
Forum discussion: fabricated claims of Syrian govt mass murder
This has been posted to johnquiggin.com. - JS, 1 Nov 14
JD (@ #17(?)) wrote on October 27th, 2014 at 20:29:
Here's part of an item I found on the website of the International League for Human Rights (FIDH):
Why didn't you include the link? I tried to find it with a search engine and couldn't.
JD continued:
The Caesar report is ... evidence smuggled out of Syria, including photographs of around 11,000 detainees' corpses. The source of the report is ... a former photographer for the Syrian military police and his job was to take pictures of killed detainees. Ten of the photos were released publicly in January 2014. The report was made available to human rights groups, governments and the UN. ...
Almost certainly this is a fabrication by the same liars who gave us Russian tanks in East Ukraine, Iraqi WMDs, incubator babies, USS Liberty, the Gulf of Tonkin incident, the Warren Commission, etc.
Until you show me where you obtained this, I cannot comment further.
As for claims that the Russian government discriminates against gays: If true, this would be of concern, but compared with the monumental violations of human rights by the Kiev regime and even more monumental violations in Iraq, Libya and Syria, the prohibition of "propaganda on non-traditional sexual relations" seems almost insignificant by comparison.
Leaders not clueless, but corrupt
Victoria's economy irrevocabably linked to population growth
Victoria has joined Tasmania as the only states where economic output per resident is shrinking. When account is taken of Victoria's strong population growth, economic output per resident shrank 0.2 per cent in 2012-13. So, without population growth artificially propping up our State's economy, we would fall into recession! Victoria's standard of living almost certainly fell in this period with flat-lining gross disposable income. Victoria now has the second lowest gross household disposable income per person in the nation, ahead of only Tasmania.
SMH:Economic output rates shrink in Victoria, Tasmania
When combined with Ford’s announced closure last year, with a total of 1,200 job losses expected in Geelong and Broadmeadows by 2016, as well as thousands of potential job losses in the Goulburn Valley region in the event that SPC Ardmona closes its operations, it is clear that Victorian manufacturing – once the mainstay of the state economy.
Over the past six years, Victoria’s economic model seems to have been built around endless population growth, with the state leading the nation.
Macrobusiness: Major employment shock coming to Victoria
Letter in The Age- 26th October
Leaders clueless
It is no wonder Lord Mayor Robert Doyle is encouraging population growth. It is the only economic input keeping the state and Melbourne, in particular, from sinking into recession. But population growth will not sustain Victoria. Eventually the added load on its underfunded and underplanned infrastructure will collapse and we will be in a highly perilous state, if we aren't already. The latest CommSec, State of the States, report paints a dismal picture for Victoria. Unemployment at a 10-year high, collapsing commercial and industrial investment and wages lagging behind inflation.
We need to be asking the parties what they plan to do to lift Victoria out of this tired and unsustainable population-driven economy. How will they create a sustainable economy with real wealth and employment growth? The problem is, our leaders and would-be leaders are very quiet regarding this debate because they don't have a clue.
Bernard Ellis, Windsor
So, we are locked into an economic model based on never-ending growth, and no politician has the courage to bear the brunt of a circuit-breaker - into a recession! With housing the main economic activity, in Victoria, houses and towers must continually be built, even where there's no infrastructure, and the approval system continually deregulated and fast-tracked, to camouflage our economy's inherent weakness!
So, even an iconic, semi-rural area out of Melbourne such as the Macedon district can't be protected from over-development! The real estate Ponzi scheme consumes everything in it's wake, and can't be stopped by runaway housing growth!
The only way is out!
Relevance of Syria's free universities to discussion about Gough
The following was posted to a discussion about Gough Whitlam on johnquiggin.com.
J-D wrote:
... discussion of the present government of Syria and discussion of the present government of Russia have only a tenuous connection to the original post ...
Gough's attempt to introduce free tertiary education was rolled back by subsequent 'Labor' and Liberal governments to the point where a perverse debt collection industry based on buying and selling debts that students incur attending university has been established in Australia as has alo occurred in the UK and other places. Syria, in the midst of wars and a terrorist insurgency, is able to provide free tertiary education to all its citizens as I showed on October 26th, 2014 at 23:29. If Syria can do it, why can't Australia, the US and the UK? Clearly this suggests that Gough was right to attempt to make University eduction free.
The other obvious link is that Bashar is, like Gough was, the target of an attempted US 'regime change' Unlike Gough, Bashar has been more successful in stopping foreign powers meddling in his country's domestic affairs.
Petition against foreign home ownership here
Kerry's failure to nominate for President no loss to humanity
@FranBarlow (11:42 21/10/1),
Given that whistleblower Ray McGovern has labeled US Secretary of State John Kerry a "serial liar" for his repeated assertions, earlier this year, that he had proof that the Syrian Government had used chemical weapons against its own people, in order to justify an invasion of Syria (which so far has lost 195,000 lives resisting US-armed terrorists) Kerry's failures to win the 2004 Presidential elections and the Democratic Party Presidential nomination in 2008, were no great losses to humanity.
Whatever his flaws may have been, Al Gore's defeat at the 2000 Presidential elections, given the scale of tragedy that humanity had to endure at the hands of President George W.Bush since then, clearly was.
Overpopulation
The coal industry's economic powerhouse
Climate change to threaten food supplies
Immigration and population policy now on We vote for you
Live exporters set to "sue" the Commonwealth over ban
The overview ignores Immigration!
Amnesty complicit in 100s of 1000s of deaths since 1990
This is a contribution to a discussion about Gough Whitlam on johnquiggin.com .
JD @ #32 wrote:
What I posted in my previous comment was ... a direct quote from an Amnesty International magazine posted to the Web.
Have you forgotten that by peddling the Kuwaiti 'incubator babies' lie in 1990 Amnesty International national facilitated over two decades of war and sanctions against Iraq? This caused the deaths of many hundreds of thousands of Iraqis. One estimate had put the total death toll since 1990 as high as 3,300,000 including 750,000 children.
I have put together some information at candobetter.net/AboutAmnestyInternational. Be sure to watch Canadian peace activist Barrie Zwicker demolish the 1990 'incubator babies' lie used to justify that war. Please feel welcome to post further comments to that page or to here.
JD wrote:
The story said nothing about the Syrian election, so anybody discussing the election is saying nothing about that story.
88% of the 74% eligible voters voted on 3 June 2014 for Bashar al-Assad - a far greater endorsement than that given to any of the Western 'leaders' hostile to the Syrian government.
Can't you see that if at the elections of 3 June 2014, the Syrian people gave President Bashar al-Assad a far greater endorsement than has been given to any of the 'leaders' of Western governments hostile to Syria that we should be even more skeptical of Amnesty's claims that that government is brutally repressing its people?
One reason for al-Assad's popularity is the government programs, including free education, including tertiary education.
Of course, this is what Gough also tried to do. However, Paul Keating, who pretends to bear the mantle of Gough's legacy, started the privatisation of tertiary education with the introduction of HECS, the Higher Education 'Contribution' Scheme in 1989 (as I have been advised elsewhere on this blog). Let's not forget that Keating and Hawke also sent our armed forces to participate in the illegal war against Iraq in 1991 and implemented the illegal sanctions that caused so many deaths that I referred to above. As a result of that and the subsequent war of 2003, 1.3 million Iraqis fled to Syria according to Wikipedia.
Respecting Whitlam's birthplace brings us together
Ironically the casual disrespect shown to Gough Whitlam's birthplace by the NFIRB and Melbourne planning has provided Victorians with their first opportunity since the Dismissal to show how much they were offended by it and how much they appreciated and cared for Gough Whitlam. Because our society is so atomised by big business and so artfully misrepresented by our monopoly press, we lack free public forums and networks whereby we can spontaneously unite to express our opinions. Instead we are usually confined to sitting in front of televisions listening to self-important talking heads give their views or reading accounts in the press of what our opinions are supposed to be. Now we find out that, not only did many of us care about Whitlam, but we still care and he is remembered and appreciated far more than any other primeminister in this country because he was the last to stand up for the very things that his successors have so shamefully sold off and destroyed. Yes, it is indeed fascinating to realise that the policies of the Foreign Investment Review Board that invite overpopulation and wasteful destruction of established buildings, might have remained unsuspected by most Australians, if Gough Whitlam had not died just before the scheduled demolition of his birthplace by a foreign purchaser. How inconvenient for the planners and the NFIRB and how convenient for democracy and the rest of us. It is as if Gough Whitlam, a primeminister who sought to reform urban and regional development by offering the people an alternative to private land speculators and to preserve Australian assets from globalisation, is having the final word.
Bob Day criticises Albanese for high density policy
457 Visa report admits risk of free-for-all
"In submissions and interviews, both employers and employees expressed dissatisfaction with the current system, employers because they say it is inflexible and does not reflect the rapidly - changing nature of the Australian labour market, and employees because they say it is too easily subverted and, in practice, can turn into a free - for - all, to the disadvantage of Australians. "Considering the number of young people dropping out of the workforce and unemployed, this deserves more attention. However as it is buried in a lengthy report it does not surprise me that it has been largely overlooked. Read it at :- http://www.immi.gov.au/pub-res/Documents/reviews/streamlined-responsive-457-programme.pdf In the same context, Easy Migrate has been running an advertisement in the West Australian newspaper featuring their 95% success rate and offering a discounted first consultation at $60 , cf regular charge of $100, for first consult. They cover a wide range of visa and migration classes, including student, visitors and permanent settlement. Feedback from users gives an interesting insight into their wide ranging "fix almost any problem” activities. P.W.
US now forcibly quarantining Ebola risks - New York
Debate questions from audience
What's happening to Gough's birthplace is happening to all of us
The irony is that Gough Whitlam condemned inflation caused by foreign buyers of Australia's assets.
His election speech of 1974, he said:"The Australian dollar was grossly undervalued. Foreign money was flooding in to buy up Australian resources and Australian industries on the cheap. ... By shelving the Trade Practices Bill they (The Senate) left the door open to monopolies and big corporations to fix prices, organise cartels and exploit the Australian customer. By shelving the Australian Industry Development Corporation Bill they blocked the most effective instrument for ensuring Australian control of our industries and developing new industries. They have left the door open to foreign takeovers and foreign exploitation of the Australian economy".
Election Speeches - Gough Whitlam 1974
What's happening to Whitlam's birth place is a micro example of what's happening to our houses, real estate, public assets and agricultural land. Inflation of house prices, deliberately manipulated as a "housing boom", thanks to heavy immigration and Australia being "open" to business! We are losing industries and businesses to free trade agreements and high rates of cheap imports flooding our markets!
It means peak property prices for those at the apex of the Ponzi scheme, the demolition of our heritage and traditional family homes, and foreigners owning properties that should be in the hands of Australians.
Our political leaders dwarf into nothing more than corporate spruikers instead of real leaders, showing statesmanship and patriotic fervour for a better life for Australians, and Australia as a unique and strong nation. Gough Whitlam had a vision for a fair and equitable Australia, with a strong singular identity, with high standards of living and nationalism. Now, we are enslaved to mortgages, renting (from foreign landlords), privatisation of public assets, paying heavy debt for a tertiary education and overloaded health care system!
Forum discussion about Gough Whitlam on JohnQuiggin.com
James
See Christopher Boyce: Burial of Gough's legacy continued after 1975, above.
Sheila Newman
Gough’s policies showed that he was well aware that the long boom was ending; he engaged with a project for energy self-sufficiency. Arguable, had he not been deposed, he might have made Australia independent, like so many other oil-producing countries of the era. (We no longer produce much oil at all, having used it all or exported it.) For more on this see “Another take on Whitlam, Population, Energy Resources, and the Khemlani loan scandal” at http://candobetter.net/node/4135. When I was engaged in a research thesis that I finished in 2002, I approached the history of the Whitlam government at an angle from which it had not previously been approached.
John Brookes
So what do we aim for? I don’t see much point in starting with the leadership of the ALP. We need to start with a vision of a world we want. Unless we have a vision, how can we sell it?
In many ways we need to go back to Gough. He wanted equality of opportunity, hence the free education and health care. Where do we go?
I look at life a bit like a game of footy on the school oval. The best game has everybody playing. But more and more we have too many people sitting on the side lines, not really wanted or needed. Out there on the oval, if the game doesn’t work for the majority of kids, then it breaks up. Kids start changing the rules until the game works again.
But right now, to stretch an analogy, we have the kids who are getting all of the footy telling us that this is the only way that footy works.
So we need someone to step up with a clear vision for remaking society so that it works for more people. Back in 1972, the conservative world was looking more and more ridiculous. Change seemed inevitable. But back in that era, there was a youth movement. They really wanted change. When I look at today's uni students, my main worry is that they are too trusting and may end up being sorely disappointed when they do all the right things and life doesn’t work out for them. We’ve already put home ownership out of reach of many.
James
This comment is 'awaiting moderation' - JS, 01:14 +10:00 25 Oct 2014
John Brooks @ #9 wrote:
@James
So what do we aim for? I don't see much point in starting with the leadership of the ALP. We need to start with a vision of a world we want. Unless we have a vision, how can we sell it?
Apologies for being so slow to respond, and apologies and that my initial response is so brief:
If you look around the world in 2014, as well as military aggression, mass murder and tyranny, there is much in the world to give us hope, but only if you remember to believe almost nothing that you read about today's geopolitical conflicts in the mainstream media .
Whilst despots, fraudsters, gangsters and fascists run much of the world, much of the rest of the world is run by people who are every bit as humane and decent as Gough was.
However, unlike Gough, they have shown themselves to be far more capable of standing up for themselves and their countries against the global forces of darkness. Of course, those same leaders are demonised by the mainstream media.
Two striking examples are Syrian President Bashar al-Assad and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Contrary to the implication manufactured by msm 'reports', both have not only been elected in certifiably democratic elections, both enjoy domestic popularity which dwarfs that of any Western leader I can think of - Tony Abbott, Barack Obama, Francois Hollande, David Cameron, Stephen Harper, Angela Merkel, Kevin Rudd, John Howard, Paul Keating, Bob Hawke, Malcolm Fraser and even Gough in 1972 and 1974.
Presidents al-Assad and Putin have also shown themselves to be far more willing to confront critical media scrutiny than any of today's Western 'leaders'. I have watched a number of interviews where both were able to demolish what has been peddled as 'news' to Western audiences. No doubt, Gough would have been able to do the same before a far less unbalanced international mass media.
Some good web sites are:
globalresearch -dot- ca, voltairenet.org, presstv -dot- com, landdestroyer -dot- blogspot -dot- com, rt -dot- com (as well as my own web site, candobetter -dot -net).
By all means, continue to read the printed msm and watch and listen to the msm broadcast media, John Brookes, but I think, over time, you will see, when you are able to compare their narratives with those on the sites such as those listed above, that little truth is to be found there.
Suggestion bushfire mitigation election policy
James,
Great suggested policies!
How about adding a bushfire mitigation policy of "Pause and review" regarding prescribed burning of Victorian Bushland. It is killing all the wildlife and, arguably, within 20 years all habitat would be so devoid of wildlife and so reduced in quality that it would all have been destroyed, to all intents and purposes. Any routine burning should only be conducted very judiciously near human infrastructure, if at all.
Hans Brunner has added the following excellent summary of the arguments:
"Before you burn think four times:
1. It kills wildlife
2. It adds to air pollution.
3. It prohibits the area to work as a carbon sink.
4. The blackened area absorbs more heat."
Maybe incorporate this?
War Culture
by David Swanson , first published on warisacrime.org, 23 Oct 2014
According to a book by George Williston called This Tribe of Mine: A Story of Anglo Saxon Viking Culture in America, the United States wages eternal war because of its cultural roots in the Germanic tribes that invaded, conquered, ethnically cleansed, or -- if you prefer -- liberated England before moving on to the slaughter of the Native Americans and then the Filipinos and Vietnamese and on down to the Iraqis. War advocate, former senator, and current presidential hopeful Jim Webb himself blames Scots-Irish American culture.
But most of medieval and ancient Europe engaged in war. How did Europe end up less violent than a place made violent by Europe? Williston points out that England spends dramatically less per capita on war than the United States does, yet he blames U.S. warmaking on English roots. And, of course, Scotland and Ireland are even further from U.S. militarism despite being closer to England and presumably to Scots-Irishness.
"We view the world through Viking eyes," writes Williston, "viewing those cultures that do not hoard wealth in the same fashion or make fine iron weapons as child-like and ripe for exploitation." Williston describes the passage of this culture down to us through the pilgrims, who came to Massachusetts and began killing -- and, quite frequently, beheading -- those less violent, acquisitive, or competitive than they.
Germans and French demonstrated greater respect for native peoples, Williston claims. But is that true? Including in Africa? Including in Auschwitz? Williston goes on to describe the United States taking over Spanish colonialism in the Philippines and French colonialism in Vietnam, without worrying too much about how Spain and France got there.
I'm convinced that a culture that favors war is necessary but not sufficient to make a population as warlike as the United States is now. All sorts of circumstances and opportunities are also necessary. And the culture is constantly evolving. Perhaps Williston would agree with me. His book doesn't make a clear argument and could really have been reduced to an essay if he'd left out the religion, the biology metaphors, the experiments proving telepathy or prayer, the long quotes of others, etc. Regardless, I think it's important to be clear that we can't blame our culture in the way that some choose to blame our genes. We have to blame the U.S. government, identify ourselves with humanity rather than a tribe, and work to abolish warmaking.
In this regard, it can only help that people like Williston and Webb are asking what's wrong with U.S. culture. It can be shocking to an Israeli to learn that their day of independence is referred to by Palestinians as The Catastrophe (Nakba), and to learn why. Similarly, many U.S. school children might be startled to know that some native Americans referred to George Washington as The Destroyer of Villages (Caunotaucarius). It can be difficult to appreciate how peaceful native Americans were, how many tribes did not wage war, and how many waged war in a manner more properly thought of as "war games" considering the minimal level of killing. As Williston points out, there was nothing in the Americas to compare with the Hundred Years War or the Thirty Years War or any of the endless string of wars in Europe -- which of course are themselves significantly removed in level of killing from wars of more recent years.
Williston describes various cooperative and peaceful cultures: the Hopi, the Kogi, the Amish, the Ladakh. Indeed, we should be looking for inspiration wherever we can find it. But we shouldn't imagine that changing our cultural practices in our homes will stop the Pentagon being the Pentagon. Telepathy and prayer are as likely to work out as levitating the Pentagon in protest. What we need is a culture dedicated to the vigorous nonviolent pursuit of the abolition of war.
Christopher Boyce: Burial of Gough's legacy continued after 1975
The following is a contribution to a discussion in response to John Quiggin's artcle Gough Whitlam (23/10/14).
Thank you, Professor Quiggin. I find the above a helpful guide to Gough's achievements that his successors and the mainstream media have tried to bury.
However, as noted by Christopher Boyce in "The Falcon Lands" episode of SBS Dateline of 18 February, the subversion of Australian democracy by no means ended in 1975. It continued until the influence of all who shared Gough's vision was marginalised within the Labor Party by the likes of Bob Carr, Paul Keating and Peter Beattie.
John Quiggin wrote:
With the failure of the global financial system now evident to all, social democratic parties have found themselves largely unable to respond.
I think that supposed social-democratic parties of the twenty-first century have shown that they are unwilling, rather than 'unable' to respond.
John Quiggin continued:
We need a renewed movement for a fairer society and a more functional economy. We can only hope for a new Whitlam to lead that movement.
So, let's try to bring that about. A good start would be the repudiation of leaders of the Labor Party, mentioned above, who have attempted to bury Labor's traditional program and have, instead, embraced economic neoliberalism and privatisation.
Irony of Matthew Guy saving Gough's house
Ironic that if Gough had set policies for Australia today
(a) built property would not have gone to a foreign buyer
(b) there would not have been incentive to destroy established houses
(c) population pressure would hardly exist
(d) we would not have developers running parliament and changing laws in their industry's favour and against citizens
Pity that Matthew doesn't step in and save homes from the East West Link.
Oh Vale Gough! Vale!
Gough's birth place saved?
Reduce social security payments by reducing immigration
Australia "running on empty"
An NRMA-commissioned report on the nation’s liquid fuel security, released in February, says that Australia’s liquid fuel stocks have slumped by 16 per cent in less than a year and that the country is now hurtling towards 100 per cent dependence on imported liquid fuel and oil for transport. Even our Defence Force will be relying on imported fuel.
Australia’s Liquid Fuel Security report is the second part of an inaugural study released last year and paints a bleak picture of a country which it says does not have a viable level of fuel security, or a government plan to improve the situation at a time when local refineries are closing.
According to the company, Australia now sources 90% of its crude and fuel imports for transport, up from just 60% in 2000. Even the Australian Navy is feeling the heat with news that the domestic supply of a special type of fuel will no longer be refined locally by mid-2014.
The NRMA-commissioned report on the nation’s liquid fuel security warns that Australia’s severely declining oil refining industry, and increasing demand for liquid fuels, could result in a scenario in 2030 where it has less than 20 days worth of fuel in reserve, and 100 per cent imported liquid fuel dependency. It's a threat to our nation's security. The report, updated by Jamison in 2010, proposed a series of steps to end Australia’s dependence on imported oil and secure its own transport energy future.
China, India, and other developing countries in Asia account for 72 per cent of the net world increase in liquid fuels consumption, with Middle East consumers accounting for another 13 per cent.
Twenty-eight per cent of the refining industry is set to close by the end of this year, according to report's author, retired Air Vice-Marshal Blackburn. The former deputy head of the RAAF also accused previous reviews of energy security of being purely economic. He urged the government to consider dropping barriers to the adoption of gas as vehicle fuel and to work with the refining industry to retain capacity in Australia. However, our LNG is being sold off at export prices for the overseas market!
The Reserve Our Gas coalition will not apologise for pointing out Australia is the only gas-exporting nation on earth allowing a free-for-all on the export of its gas. Australian gas prices are projected to triple over coming years as a result.
“Let me make this absolutely crystal clear: Australia is the only nation on earth allowing multinational gas companies to extract our gas - without restriction - and sell it back to us at the high global price,” AWU National Secretary and Reserve Our Gas spokesperson Mr McDine said.
According to the ABS, renewable energy extraction, which has been steadily increasing since 2008-09, decreased in 2011-12 by 15 PJ and remains at 2% of total domestic energy production. Solar energy extraction increased by 3 PJ, or 21% and hydro-electricity supply, which fluctuates according to water availability, decreased by 10 PJ, or 16%. Our government's belief in the cornucopia myth, and anti-science stance, could finally jeopardize the eternal "growth" paradigm!
Demolition of Gough's birth place
Live export system is failing, and is unable to protect animals
Whitlam lowered immigration levels
Lowest rate of foreign ownership was under Whitlam
Time to leave
Whitlam's greatest plan was buying back Australian assets
Gough
Lack of intellectual capacity crippling Australia
Melbourne is going skyhigh, as so are complaints
People are complaining because of lack of planning - and what's happening is that Melbourne and it's suburbs are being wantonly surrendered to property developers and planners for their vested interests. Behind the "population growth" is demographic engineering, or massive increases in net overseas immigration - not organic or natural reproductive rates!
Between 2000 and 2001, net overseas immigration numbers were are about 80.000. Now the numbers have soared to 241,000 permanent immigration and set to increase again next year. (not counting humanitarian intake or New Zealanders who do not require a visa).
The public are not being given any right to query the overwhelming of Melbourne by housing growth, and suburbs being forced to accept high density housing at the detriment of living standards and traditional values.
We need some real economic activities, not just a heavy reliance on the overly easy option of housing - and the downstream costs of population growth.
Any other method of stimulating our economy, apart for amassing people, would take innovation, thought, planning and intellectual capacity. Population growth, the selling off of our housing and "lifestyle", is a no-brainer and an easy option. Real economic growth requires investment in productivity, knowledge industries, and creativity, A flow of immigrants is a short-term option, one that produces cash flows but downstream accumulates massive infrastructure debts, and actually dilutes the "lifestyle" that's being promoted!
As writer Donald Horne said, "Australia is a Lucky Country, run mainly by second-rate people who share its luck".
SMH:Melbourne going skyhigh but so are complaints about planning at http://www.smh.com.au/national/education/melbournes-going-skyhigh-but-so-are-complaints-about-planning-20141016-116vxe.html
Oliver Stone to produce biopic on Edward Snowden
Liabilities as an assett
Australians the world's richest thanks to property
Animal Justice Party to contest Victorian elections
From Animal Justice Party trots, waddles and runs for Parliament (4/10/14) by Farah Tomazin from the Age:
It was a pre-election rally for creatures great and small.
Some wanted jumps racing banned. Others wanted a genuine crackdown on puppy farms. And some called for an end to ducks being killed in the name of sport.
With eights weeks until the state election, activists, politicians, pets and owners gathered on the steps of state parliament on Saturday united by a single cause: animal welfare.
The newest micro party to be registered this week - the Animal Justice Party – used the forum to put the major parties on notice, particular in the upper house, where the balance of power is up for grabs.
More than 20 candidates would contest November's poll, convener Bruce Poon declared, "and they're standing for, and on behalf of animals, who can't do it for themselves."
The crowd also called for jumps racing to be banned. However, Dr Napthine – who is also Victoria's racing minister – is a strong supporter of jumps racing and argues that government investment has improved safety over the years.
Editorial comment: Whilst candobetter.net fully endorses the Animal Justice Party, having a large number of 'micro-parties' like the Animal Justice Party contesting the ballot poses problems for Victorian voters. As the article above indicates, a large number of issues, apart from animal justice will be decided on 29 November. It is our hope that each Victorian voter will be given an opportunity to vote for at least one candidate, in his/her own electorate as well as in the upper house, who takes what we consider to be the correct, principled stance on all of the issues listed above including animal justice.
Were a voter to be be faced with a number of candidates each supporting only a single, if laudable cause, we recommend that that voter get around this with the preferential voting system. If she/he decides to give her/his first preference to the Animal Justice Party, then she/he should give her/his second, then third and fourth preferences to other candidates who are in favour of some or all of the other policies listed above and he/she should be sure to put preferences for those parties ahead of preferences for either of the major party candidates. It may make a difference, particularly in the upper house.
Candidates' replies